- (#16) ’03-’04 Tampa Bay Lightning vs. (#17) ’98-’99 Carolina Hurricanes
- (#3) ’07-’08 Detroit Red Wings vs. (#35) ’08-’09 Minnesota Wild
- (#6) ’12-’13 Chicago Blackhawks vs. (#27) ’79-’80 Minnesota North Stars
- (#10) ’12-’13 Pittsburgh Penguins vs. (#23) ’79-’80 Buffalo Sabres
- (#14) ’13-’14 Los Angeles Kings vs. (#19) ’88-’89 Calgary Flames
- (#7) ’25-’26 Ottawa Senators vs. (#39) ’78-’79 Atlanta Flames
- (#13) ’34-’35 Montreal Maroons vs. (#20) ’02-’03 Dallas Stars
- (#2) ’61-’62 Toronto Maple Leafs vs. (#34) ’10-’11 Nashville Predators
- (#9) ’71-’72 New York Rangers vs. (#24) ’07-’08 Florida Panthers
- (#4) ’73-’74 Boston Bruins vs. (#36) ’12-’13 Columbus Blue Jackets
- (#15) ’73-’74 Philadelphia Flyers vs. (#18) ’06-’07 Anaheim Ducks
- (#1) ’76-’77 Montreal Canadiens vs. (#33) ’83-’84 Quebec Nordiques
- (#8) ’78-’79 New York Islanders vs. (#25) ’05-’06 Ottawa Senators
- (#5) ’83-’84 Edmonton Oilers vs. (#28) ’09-’10 San Jose Sharks
- (#12) ’95-’96 Colorado Avalanche vs. (#21) ’99-’00 St. Louis Blues
- (#11) ’96-’97 New Jersey Devils vs. (#22) ’10-’11 Vancouver Canucks
